Spin,
As part of our boat shopping and purchase this summer, after deciding exactly what we wanted (43 DC or MY) and what the market value was, I prepared an email message explaining what I was looking for and what I was willing to pay and sent it to every broker with a boat that appeared on Yachtworld to meet our criteria and was in a suitable geographic location. I noted that their asking price was out of the range of what I appreciated the current market value to be, and invited them to respond IF their boat could actually be purchased in my price range.
I received several interesting and helpful responses, and did identify boats whose owners and brokers appreciated market value based upon current comparable sales. One of the responding brokers, graciously provided me with a list of recent sales which seemed to confirm that the NADA price (without extras) was pretty consistent with sales comparables. As it turned out, separate from the mass email I located the boat we actually bought, but the email was well worth the time and probably would have located a suitable boat.
In addition I learned not to go and see a boat without a prior understanding of what the actual selling price was. It made the most sense to me, before taking time and spending money traveling to see a boat, to first obtain an appreciation from the photos and broker as to condition and equipment, and if the selling price was in range, make an offer with deposit, contingent on inspection, sea trial and survey. Only after my conditional offer was accepted would we spent the time and money to go look at and sea trial the boat.
We did this, dealing with very professional broker, Greg Somerville at Galati. The boat was as represented, the boat passed survey and we paid the price previously agreed.
My approach and experience may be helpful to you and I pass it on. It may not be the way to get the very lowest price, but a good boat at a fair price was good enough.
Regards,
Vincent