Your question implies that somehow the amount of lead you carry around in your batteries is directly related to the performance of a battery. That's not necessarily the case with quickly evolving technology in the battery world.
I'm on year two with the Fullriver DC200-8 AGM's and couldn't be happier. Here's what I "gave up" by ditching conventional lead acid batteries.
I I gave up on routine maintenance for batteries. No more watering and dealing with battery acid and all the nasty stuff that goes with it. Check the battery connections for corrosion twice a season and call it a day.
2. I gave up the old, rotted OEM battery boxes for some really nice, clean looking NOCO boxes that fit in roughly half the space.
3. I gave up on trying to hump 167 lb batteries up and over the generator to get them into the original battery boxes, in some cases coming dangerously close to spilling battery acid on myself.
These are just a few of the things I gave up in dealing with conventional batteries. Lots of great info both pro and con for lead acid batteries and I've spoken to many Hatt owners that have gotten ten years or more out of Deka or Rolls batteries.
As mentioned in a previous comment, battery costs are coming down and there was very little difference for us in the purchase of the AGM's versus conventional lead acid. I think we paid roughly $50.00 more per battery for the AGM's.