Is this something new that has just started happening? Does it happen consistently in all waves and current conditions? Do the gear oil pressures read the same the first time as they do the following times, or is there a difference after it heats up? If all the readings are the same the 2nd time you go to 2650 but it won't plane, that's very strange, particularly if it'll plane if you start from zero again.
How's this for a wierd scenario: Your trim tabs hydraulics lose pressure slowly and can't hold the position you have them set for. When you are at zero, they can go to the correct position because there's no force against them. Then when you get underway, one or both slowly move back up and you drop off plane and can't get it back up while underway because the trim tabs are now set too level so you're nose up, even at 2650. If you go back to idle, the trim tabs can reset slowly to the correct position so it's now ready to repeat.
If you have stabilizers and one trim tabs goes up, the stabilizers will fight to offset that producing drag and worsen the effect.
Doug Shuman