Thank goodness your boat survived! I like a variety of fenders for different applications. I have two Megafend 90's (18"x40") with polar fleece covers, two 12"x36" Taylormade inflatables with polar fleece covers, two 10"x30" Taylormade inflatables with polar fleece covers and I have one large Polyform F-series as well when I need something really large.
The Megafends work very well because they are not filled with air, they are solid core. If you are docking and come in with an extra knot or two and deploy one it will absorb the shock with little rebound as opposed to bouncing you off the dock like the inflatable fenders do. They are a little pricey, but you can find them used if you look around. The Mega 70 would probably be the perfect size for our boats at 12"x35". I got my pair of 90's used from a fellow HOF member and rebuilt/recovered them to like new.
Go exchange those blown out Taylor Mades for new ones. Think of what changes you may want to make on your fender lineup, but apparently the setup you had worked quite well! CONGRATS!!